James 4:1-12 – When You Don’t Get What You Want
The world is a rather contentious place. Whether we’re considering international politics or the preschool playground, you’re going to find people bickering with each other. As our passage today points out, these quarrels generally arise from the same situation: people want something that they don’t have, or they want to keep something that other people want to get from them. It doesn’t matter if it’s two preschoolers arguing over a favorite toy or countries negotiating with each other over a trade deal or a peace treaty. We see it everywhere. People dispute with each other because they want something they don’t have, or they want more what they already have, or they want to make sure others don’t get what they have. The only thing that changes is what the “it” is that people are fighting over, or the way that they handle their disagreements. People steal to get what they want from other people. Labor unions and corporate officials negotiate over salary packages. Retailers undercut each other’s prices. Sports teams do everything they can to get the edge over the competition in order to win; sometimes they do what the New England Patriots did and break the rules to do so. Spend some time thinking about it, and you’ll see the point. All kinds of conflicts and struggles are based on the fact that people want “stuff,” and do what they can to get it from other people.
This desire to get stuff dates back to Adam and Eve.
We have desires within us that keep driving us.
Relates to last of 10 commandments: one that addresses attitude & not action: coveting
As long as we strive to satisfy that itch w/in us to satisfy desires, we’ll never be content.
Desires are like poison ivy rash: the more you scratch them, the stronger your desire is to scratch them.
December 26 syndrome: there’s no such thing as having all your desires met.
We may experience those moments when we’re so happy with something new that we got that we get a momentary rush of happiness. But it doesn’t take long until the moment is gone, and our desires have rushed on to the next desire that fills us.
So we start to pursue the next desire, like a junkie who wants the next rush. So we go off to the after-Christmas sales even before our Christmas presents have lost their shine: there’s still more that we want.
We’re like the wealthy tycoon who had amassed a vast fortune, but was still working tirelessly to earn even more. Someone asked him how more money he’d need before he could rest content, and he replied, “The answer is the same answer that I’ve given my entire life: just one more dollar, and it will be enough.”
Sometimes, some of us realize how insane this progression is. We see that we’re chasing a mirage that we’ll never catch. The end of the rainbow looks like it’s just over the next hill, but we know that when we get there, it’s moved on, still just beyond our reach. So, if we’re wise, we stop the race to satisfy our desires. We resign ourselves to the fact that there will always be some things that we wish we had that we never will. We congratulate ourselves on our self-restraint and insight. It doesn’t make us any happier, but at least we aren’t wearing ourselves out. We’ve just learned to accept the pangs of unfulfilled desires, just like you can get used to an annoying rattle in your car.
Or, if we’re somewhat religious, then we realize that we can get God in this act of ours. God can do anything, and God says that he loves us. So, we tell ourselves, what could be more loving than giving us what we desire? After all, we’re convinced that the thing which will make us most happy is to receive whatever it is that our desires are pushing us toward. If God gives it to us, then we’ll be happy. And, we tell ourselves, this is perfectly Biblical. After all, doesn’t Psalm 20 contain that wonderful blessing: “May he give you the desire of your heart, and make all your plans succeed…. May the LORD grant all your requests”? And didn’t Jesus tell us, “my Father will give you whatever you ask”? And here in this passage, James tells us that “you do not have, because you do ask God.” So, the answer seems to be, we need to bring our requests to God, and he’ll fill them for us. This line of reasoning has a powerful appeal for many people. Vast religious empires have been built, and continue to be built, which are based on the notion that if we learn exactly the right way to ask, God will give us what we want. He’s better than Santa Claus, because he can do it 365 days a year, not just one. The preachers say, “God wants to bless you! Let me tell you how you can get it.”
But when they quote today’s passage, they conveniently stop before verse 3. Yes, James wrote that we do not have, because we do not ask God. But he went on to say, “When you ask, you do not receive, because you ask with the wrong motives, that you may spend what you get on your pleasures.” When Jesus said that the Father will give us what we want, he told us that we had to ask “in his name.” This doesn’t mean that the name “Jesus” is a magic password to get us into the heavenly goody-jar. It means that we must be conformed to the personhood of Jesus in order to receive. Our lives must be remade in Christ’s image. And yes, Psalm 20 seeks the blessing of receiving the desires of our hearts. But Psalm 37 gives us a bit more of an explanation: “Delight yourself in the LORD and he will give you the desires of your heart.” In other words, when your desires are focused upon the delight of the Lord, not upon the satisfaction of your cravings, you will find the satisfaction you’ve been looking for.
James tells us that we have a choice to make. Our first choice is to continue to live in what he calls “friendship with the world.” We can continue to live life and accept the values of the kind of lives we’ve inherited from Adam and Eve, who traded their fellowship with God for a taste of the one fruit they were told they couldn’t have. In other words, we can continue to seek for satisfaction and meaning by pursuing the desires we have within us. But, even if we convince ourselves that we are chasing these desires in a religious way by asking God to give them to us, we are an enemy of God. We display hatred to God. That may sound harsh, but sometimes the truth hurts. We’re dedicating our lives to a pursuit that separates us from God and rejects his place in our lives.
James calls us to accept a different choice. It is the choice of humility and submission. It is a humble recognition that we can never satisfy ourselves. It is a submission to the power of God. We do not have the power or ability to quiet those cravings and desires within us. They’re simply too strong, and we are too weak. But God offers us an opportunity to become new, different people. It can happen not by the force of our human will, but by the power of Jesus Christ, who alone can undo the disease of desire that affects us all.
This desire to get stuff dates back to Adam and Eve.
We have desires within us that keep driving us.
Relates to last of 10 commandments: one that addresses attitude & not action: coveting
As long as we strive to satisfy that itch w/in us to satisfy desires, we’ll never be content.
Desires are like poison ivy rash: the more you scratch them, the stronger your desire is to scratch them.
December 26 syndrome: there’s no such thing as having all your desires met.
We may experience those moments when we’re so happy with something new that we got that we get a momentary rush of happiness. But it doesn’t take long until the moment is gone, and our desires have rushed on to the next desire that fills us.
So we start to pursue the next desire, like a junkie who wants the next rush. So we go off to the after-Christmas sales even before our Christmas presents have lost their shine: there’s still more that we want.
We’re like the wealthy tycoon who had amassed a vast fortune, but was still working tirelessly to earn even more. Someone asked him how more money he’d need before he could rest content, and he replied, “The answer is the same answer that I’ve given my entire life: just one more dollar, and it will be enough.”
Sometimes, some of us realize how insane this progression is. We see that we’re chasing a mirage that we’ll never catch. The end of the rainbow looks like it’s just over the next hill, but we know that when we get there, it’s moved on, still just beyond our reach. So, if we’re wise, we stop the race to satisfy our desires. We resign ourselves to the fact that there will always be some things that we wish we had that we never will. We congratulate ourselves on our self-restraint and insight. It doesn’t make us any happier, but at least we aren’t wearing ourselves out. We’ve just learned to accept the pangs of unfulfilled desires, just like you can get used to an annoying rattle in your car.
Or, if we’re somewhat religious, then we realize that we can get God in this act of ours. God can do anything, and God says that he loves us. So, we tell ourselves, what could be more loving than giving us what we desire? After all, we’re convinced that the thing which will make us most happy is to receive whatever it is that our desires are pushing us toward. If God gives it to us, then we’ll be happy. And, we tell ourselves, this is perfectly Biblical. After all, doesn’t Psalm 20 contain that wonderful blessing: “May he give you the desire of your heart, and make all your plans succeed…. May the LORD grant all your requests”? And didn’t Jesus tell us, “my Father will give you whatever you ask”? And here in this passage, James tells us that “you do not have, because you do ask God.” So, the answer seems to be, we need to bring our requests to God, and he’ll fill them for us. This line of reasoning has a powerful appeal for many people. Vast religious empires have been built, and continue to be built, which are based on the notion that if we learn exactly the right way to ask, God will give us what we want. He’s better than Santa Claus, because he can do it 365 days a year, not just one. The preachers say, “God wants to bless you! Let me tell you how you can get it.”
But when they quote today’s passage, they conveniently stop before verse 3. Yes, James wrote that we do not have, because we do not ask God. But he went on to say, “When you ask, you do not receive, because you ask with the wrong motives, that you may spend what you get on your pleasures.” When Jesus said that the Father will give us what we want, he told us that we had to ask “in his name.” This doesn’t mean that the name “Jesus” is a magic password to get us into the heavenly goody-jar. It means that we must be conformed to the personhood of Jesus in order to receive. Our lives must be remade in Christ’s image. And yes, Psalm 20 seeks the blessing of receiving the desires of our hearts. But Psalm 37 gives us a bit more of an explanation: “Delight yourself in the LORD and he will give you the desires of your heart.” In other words, when your desires are focused upon the delight of the Lord, not upon the satisfaction of your cravings, you will find the satisfaction you’ve been looking for.
James tells us that we have a choice to make. Our first choice is to continue to live in what he calls “friendship with the world.” We can continue to live life and accept the values of the kind of lives we’ve inherited from Adam and Eve, who traded their fellowship with God for a taste of the one fruit they were told they couldn’t have. In other words, we can continue to seek for satisfaction and meaning by pursuing the desires we have within us. But, even if we convince ourselves that we are chasing these desires in a religious way by asking God to give them to us, we are an enemy of God. We display hatred to God. That may sound harsh, but sometimes the truth hurts. We’re dedicating our lives to a pursuit that separates us from God and rejects his place in our lives.
James calls us to accept a different choice. It is the choice of humility and submission. It is a humble recognition that we can never satisfy ourselves. It is a submission to the power of God. We do not have the power or ability to quiet those cravings and desires within us. They’re simply too strong, and we are too weak. But God offers us an opportunity to become new, different people. It can happen not by the force of our human will, but by the power of Jesus Christ, who alone can undo the disease of desire that affects us all.
